| Theme

This tile is from The railroad quilt (Ruled Quilt)

Comment: end of the line and a tunnel by a river?
Checked out at: August 28, 2001
Checked in at: August 28, 2001
Checkout tile:


Low score??
A 2.2?? Aww come on! Can you at least tell me why??
Re: Low score??
As far as I'm concerned, I voted a 2. Reason? You didn't continue ANY of the track. Especially the track from the top I was really exited on seeing what would happen with it. And you just, stopped it. You didn't have to stop it. There where several solutions you could have used, instead of drawing a tunnel.

Think of it this way:
Style of the picture, +4
Not continuing the top track, -1.5
Poor usage of the top-left track, -0.5
Result: 2

Hope you take no offense, I like many of your tiles.
Re: Re: Low score??
But I did continue the top track! It just went through a tunnel and came out on the bottom! I couldn't really come up with a way of continuing the top-left track and the top track together... so I kinda made it end at a cliff... sorta. And with all due respect, I can't help but think that you voted low because it didn't turn out how you would have liked. And I guess that's ok, cuz I think we're all a little guilty of that occasionally :) And wait a minute... did you just say you like some of my tiles? Wait, no, you said "many"! Are you on medication of any sorts? :)
Re: Re: Re: Low score??
Heh... I had a hangover when writing it... Where's the line between many and some? ... I've given you more than three fives (and then I didn't care to count check any more of your tiles for what score I had given them)... maybe that even qualifies as many? =) anyway. ... uhh... nothing... keep on tiling =)
Re: Re: Re: Re: Low score??
Fives??? No way! Hey uh.. *wink wink* whatcha think of my Fangorn tile? ;)
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Low score??
Fangorn... That's the ent, right? ... I gave it a four... If the axe hadn't been there... maybe it would have been a 5...
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Low score??
I KNEW IT!!! DAMN AXE!!! What was I thinking??