| Theme

This tile is from Newbies 32 - The Next Generation


Comment: Gulliver's travels in an empty paint tin
Checked out at: March 03, 2004
Checked in at: March 03, 2004
Checkout tile:

Posts

kodgetts
IMHO...
...I think this is my best tile yet. I've started getting used to using layers effectively, which helped me particularly with the message in a bottle. :^)
kodgetts
Re: IMHO...
OK... which one of you gave me a '0'?

That is unbelievably harsh!! >:^(

If you can offer a good reason why then I'd like to hear it...
kodgetts
Re: Re: IMHO...
Huh... now I have a -3 as well?!

Anyone care to give me some constructive criticism here?? >:^/
DanteLives
Re: Re: Re: IMHO...
I really like this tile and think that it's one of your best. Its only weakness in my opinion is the upper border; a band of stars and maybe a hint of the hat and telescope isn't much to work with. I voted 4 but I think I'll go ahead and change that to a 5. ;)
kodgetts
Re: Re: Re: Re: IMHO...
I agree with you about the top border... and thanks for the very generous 5! :^D

So I take it that whoever gave me the 0 and -3 had quite a dramatic change of heart then?
Lo_
Re: Re: Re: IMHO...
the shading lacks a lot in this tile. the tin and the bottle both look like they're not really coming out of the water, just pasted on. The water also looks pretty flat. The stars in the background looks very unrefined. What I did like is the character which is well drawn. I gave it a 3.
kodgetts
Re: Re: Re: Re: IMHO...
Yeah, I guess I don't do photo-realism...

I'm surprised that you think the character is well drawn, as that was a very quick afterthought. I guess it looks OK because its so small - if I had attempted a larger figure I believe you would think very differently.

Thanks for your comments! :^)